Acoustic vs. Electric Guitars: Which One Hits the Right Note for You?

Deciding between an acoustic and electric guitar is like choosing your first car—do you want the rugged, classic Jeep or the sleek, high-tech Tesla? Both guitars have their unique charm, and the right choice depends on what makes your heart (and fingers) sing.

This guide will help you settle the acoustic-versus-electric debate by breaking down the similarities, differences, and advantages of each type. Whether you're dreaming of campfire singalongs or arena-rocking solos, we’ve got you covered.

What Acoustic and Electric Guitars Have in Common

Think of acoustic and electric guitars as siblings. Sure, they have their quirks, but deep down, they share the same DNA:

• Tuning pegs, frets, and fretboards: These essentials shape your sound and technique on both instruments.

• Chords, scales, and techniques: Master one, and you’ll have a head start on the other. 

• Practice Makes Perfect: Whether you’re playing a soulful acoustic melody or shredding an electric solo, consistent practice is the secret sauce.

So, no matter which guitar you pick, it’s your dedication that will make you a rockstar.

Acoustic vs. Electric Guitars: The Key Differences

Like any sibling rivalry, acoustic and electric guitars have their distinctions. Let’s compare:

• Body Type: Acoustics use a hollow body and sound hole for natural resonance, while electrics rely on pickups and amps for their sound.

• Comfort Level: Acoustic guitars tend to be bulkier, while electrics are slim and sleek—though they can feel heavier.

• Playability: Electric guitars are easier on the fingers with their thin necks and lighter strings. Acoustics, with their wider necks and heavier strings, demand more finger strength but build great technique.

• Portability: Acoustics win here. No amps or cables required—just grab and go. Electric guitars need their entourage of gear. 

Why You'll Love an Acoustic Guitar

• Plug-and-Play Simplicity: No amp, no cables, no fuss. Just tune it and strum away.

• Classic Sound and Style: Acoustics shine in genres like folk, country, and classical, offering a warm, timeless tone.

• Beginner-Friendly: Tougher strings build finger strength, setting you up for success on any stringed instrument.

• Travel Buddy: Whether it’s a bonfire or a road trip, acoustics are always ready for action.

Perfect for: Singer-songwriters, folk enthusiasts, and those who want a no-fuss, no-plug instrument.

Why You’ll Love an Electric Guitar

• Endless Sound Options: From clean sounds to heavy metal distortion, electrics are chameleons.

• Beginner’s Best Friend: Easier-to-press strings and thinner necks mean less finger fatigue.

• Volume Control: Keep it low for practice or crank it up for performances—the choice is yours.

• Stage Presence: Sleek, edgy, and built for the spotlight.

Perfect for: Rockers, blues, R&B, punk, grunge alternative, funk, indie rock and anyone who loves experimenting with effects pedals and tone. 

Beginner Friendly Guitar Accessories Guide 

When it comes to picking your first guitar, the fun doesn’t stop at the instrument itself. To truly hit the ground running, you’ll need a few essential accessories. Think of these as your guitar’s entourage—helping you play better, stay in tune, and keep your instrument safe.

Here’s the ultimate beginner-friendly list to get you strumming (or shredding) in no time:

Guitar Amplifier: Bring the Noise (or Keep It Chill)

If you’re team electric, an amp is non-negotiable. A small “practice amp” is perfect for beginners, offering just enough power without shaking the walls. Interested in rock, pop, or blues? Look for a “two-channel” amp that can switch between clean and distorted tones—it’s like having two amps in one!

Instrument Cable: The Lifeline Between Guitar and Amp

Your electric guitar needs a solid connection to the amp, and that’s where the instrument cable comes in. Make sure it’s long enough to reach from your amp to your favorite chair or stool—about 10 feet is a safe bet. Bonus points for snagging a cable with reinforced ends to avoid fraying. 

Headphones: Practice in Peace (for Everyone’s Sake)

Many amps come with headphone jacks, and trust us, your neighbors and pets will thank you for using them. Pop on a pair of good headphones to keep your practice private while still enjoying every crisp note or gritty riff.

Guitar Tuner: Stay Pitch-Perfect

Whether you’re playing an acoustic or electric, a tuner is your best friend. Acoustic players will need a tuner with a built-in mic, while electric players can go for a plug-in version. Headstock tuners, which clip onto your guitar and use vibration to detect pitch, are a great all-around choice. Bonus: Most tuners are budget-friendly, so there’s no excuse for being out of tune!

Guitar Picks: Tiny Tools, Big Impact

These little plastic wonders are what make your strings sing. Picks come in a range of thicknesses, but if you’re just starting out, go for “medium” picks—they’re the Goldilocks of the pick world. As you progress, you’ll develop a preference for thickness and materials.

Guitar Strap: Play Standing Up Like a Pro

Straps aren’t just for electric guitars; many acoustics can rock them too. Look for an adjustable strap that feels comfortable during long practice sessions. Test it out first—your shoulder will thank you later. 

Extra Strings: Because Snaps Happen

Strings are like the tires of your guitar—they’ll eventually wear out. Always keep a spare set on hand so a broken string doesn’t ruin your practice or performance. Just make sure to grab the right type—acoustic and electric guitars require different strings.

Guitar Case: Protection for Your Precious Instrument

Whether you’re commuting to lessons or heading out for a jam session, a case is a must-have. A soft case (or “gig bag”) is lightweight and perfect for everyday use. If you’re traveling more extensively—or flying—a hard case offers extra protection for your prized possession.

Guitar Sizes and Scale Length: Finding the Perfect Fit

When it comes to guitars, size matters—especially for younger players or those just starting out. Manufacturers offer a range of options, including full-size guitars, as well as ¾ and ½ size models, designed to make playing more comfortable for smaller hands. These scaled-down versions are often referred to as “short-scale guitars” due to their shorter necks.

What Is Scale Length, Anyway?

Think of scale length as the part of the string that vibrates when you play a note. It’s measured from the nut (the top of the neck) to the saddle (where the strings rest on the bridge). This length plays a big role in how the guitar feels and sounds.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Long Scale (25–25.5 inches): The standard for full-size guitars. These offer a brighter tone and firmer string tension, which can be great for more experienced players.

• Short Scale (21–24.5 inches): Found on ¾ and ½ size guitars, these are easier to handle for younger players or those with smaller hands. Less string tension also means they’re softer on the fingers—perfect for beginners!

Why Scale Length Matters

Since all guitars use the same string sets, shorter scale guitars naturally have less tension when tuned. This gives them a slightly warmer tone and makes pressing down on the strings easier—a win-win for comfort and playability.

Which Size Should You Choose?

• For Kids and Beginners: Go for ¾ or ½ size guitars with a short scale—they’re easier to hold and play.

• For Teens and Adults: A full-size guitar with a standard scale length is a great choice once you’ve built some hand strengh.

Remember, comfort is key when choosing a guitar. A properly sized instrument can make all the difference in your learning journey.

How to Decide: Key Questions to Consider when choosing between an acoustic or electric

What Music Do You Love?

• Acoustic guitars excel in unplugged genres like folk and country.
• Electric guitars dominate rock, metal, and Indie scenes.

Where Will You Play?

• Acoustic: Ideal for outdoor gigs and spontaneous jam sessions.
• Electric: Best for home practice or venues with an amp setup.

What’s Your Budget?

• Acoustic guitars are typically more affordable since they require no extra gear.
• Acoustics start at $200, while electrics with accessories can increase your budget upwards of $300 to $500.

Do You Like to Experiment?

• If effects pedals and tonal exploration excite you, an electric guitar is the way to go.

Why Not Both?

Still can’t decide? Start with one and add the other later. Or go hybrid with an acoustic-electric guitar for the best of both worlds. 

Top Picks for Every Guitarist

For Acoustic Enthusiasts:

• Washburn Bella Tono Novo S9: Affordable with a compact body and tonal clarity.
• Oscar Schmidt OG: 3/4 size guitar perfect for younger players (ages 7- 10) and people with smaller hands.
• Washburn G7SCE: Acoustic-Electric Guitar with a solid spruce top and select mahogany back and side pairing, making it unparalleled in its price range.

For Electric Enthusiasts:

• Washburn Sonamaster: Exceptional tone, playability, and style without breaking the bank.
• Cort G250 SE: Built with high-quality components, engineered to deliver performance reliability for players of all styles.
• Oscar Schmidt OS-300: Classic shape and Classic Tone
• Oscar Schmidt 0S-30: 3/4 size version of the OS300, the OS-30 is the perfect guitar for younger players.

Conclusion: Start Your Musical Journey Today

Choosing between an acoustic and electric guitar isn’t just about the instrument—it’s about what inspires you. Whether you want to strum heartfelt ballads or electrify the stage, there’s a guitar waiting to bring your music to life.

Ready to find your dream guitar? At MusicStox, we have a curated collection of acoustic, electric, and hybrid guitars for every style and budget. Browse our guitar selection or reach out for personalized recommendations.